By Lindsey
#3141
Andrea wrote:
Mon May 08, 2017 9:42:19 pm
Lindsey wrote:
Mon May 08, 2017 9:41:18 pm
You know.... just throwing it out there....
why didn't anyone say anything about this before, though? even garrett didn't say it, he just told me "oh yeah spencer has the idol" with no explanation.
Because it's not worth mentioning something about the majority to the majority.
User avatar
 

Lindsey

  • Juror
  • Posts: 675
By Steve
#3142 If Spencer was the target last tribal, that piece of info woulda been a nice bargaining chip, I'd think?
User avatar
 

Steve

  • Juror
  • Posts: 667
By Nick
#3143
Lindsey wrote:
Mon May 08, 2017 9:43:23 pm
Andrea wrote:
Mon May 08, 2017 9:42:19 pm
Lindsey wrote:
Mon May 08, 2017 9:41:18 pm
You know.... just throwing it out there....
why didn't anyone say anything about this before, though? even garrett didn't say it, he just told me "oh yeah spencer has the idol" with no explanation.
Because it's not worth mentioning something about the majority to the majority.
it may have been worth mentioning before today, but you know.
User avatar
 

Nick

  • Juror
  • Posts: 1337
By Andrea
#3144
LJ wrote:
Mon May 08, 2017 9:42:56 pm
I think it's considered rude to accuse someone of intentionally posting an accidentally public confessional.
somehow i don't believe that would stop garrett...
User avatar
 

Andrea

  • Juror
  • Posts: 1315
By Andrea
#3145
Steve wrote:
Mon May 08, 2017 9:44:05 pm
If Spencer was the target last tribal, that piece of info woulda been a nice bargaining chip, I'd think?
one WOULD think wouldn't one
User avatar
 

Andrea

  • Juror
  • Posts: 1315
By Spencer
#3146
Lindsey wrote:
Mon May 08, 2017 9:39:28 pm
Andrea wrote:
Mon May 08, 2017 9:38:32 pm
LJ wrote:
Mon May 08, 2017 9:37:36 pm
Not to be Tai's constant defender or anything, but I thought we voted Spencer because he has the Hadiboh idol and we were trying to surprise him?
why do we think that Spencer has the idol? he didn't get any of the clues.

I mean, on New Habidoh Garrett told me he had it, but Garrett also told me...a lot of things, so.
you didn't see the "accidental" confessional he posted to the tribe page about lying to Garrett about having the idol. Seemed too coincidental.
I told Garrett about having an idol the night Woo was voted off, I accidentally posted a confessional in the tribe forum admitting I'd lied about it like a day or two later, and I guess Garrett told them I had an idol like an hour before I posted it, so that looked suspicious. I didn't know he told them until yesterday so it's literally just a coincidence.
User avatar
 

Spencer

  • Juror
  • Posts: 564
By Lindsey
#3147 Why would we tell you who we're voting for when we think they have the idol, and you're aligned with them? You could tell them as a heads up?
User avatar
 

Lindsey

  • Juror
  • Posts: 675
By LJ
#3148
Andrea wrote:
Mon May 08, 2017 9:44:24 pm
LJ wrote:
Mon May 08, 2017 9:42:56 pm
I think it's considered rude to accuse someone of intentionally posting an accidentally public confessional.
somehow i don't believe that would stop garrett...
I'll just take this opportunity to say hi to Garrett. I think you were fun and I enjoyed talking to you.
User avatar
 

LJ

  • Al-Mahrah Tribe
  • Posts: 308
By Andrea
#3149
Spencer wrote:
Mon May 08, 2017 9:45:22 pm
Lindsey wrote:
Mon May 08, 2017 9:39:28 pm
Andrea wrote:
Mon May 08, 2017 9:38:32 pm


why do we think that Spencer has the idol? he didn't get any of the clues.

I mean, on New Habidoh Garrett told me he had it, but Garrett also told me...a lot of things, so.
you didn't see the "accidental" confessional he posted to the tribe page about lying to Garrett about having the idol. Seemed too coincidental.
I told Garrett about having an idol the night Woo was voted off, I accidentally posted a confessional in the tribe forum admitting I'd lied about it like a day or two later, and I guess Garrett told them I had an idol like an hour before I posted it, so that looked suspicious. I didn't know he told them until yesterday so it's literally just a coincidence.
why did you tell garrett you had an idol, though? and why would he believe it, where would you have gotten it??
User avatar
 

Andrea

  • Juror
  • Posts: 1315
By Andrea
#3150
Lindsey wrote:
Mon May 08, 2017 9:45:36 pm
Why would we tell you who we're voting for when we think they have the idol, and you're aligned with them? You could tell them as a heads up?
i mean why wouldn't you make sure you had all 6 voting with you. there's a lot about last vote i don't understand, lol.
User avatar
 

Andrea

  • Juror
  • Posts: 1315
By Tai
#3151 Garrett for #GameChangers

because this boy is still relevant. LOL
User avatar
 

Tai

  • Al-Mahrah Tribe
  • Posts: 293
By Nick
#3152
Lindsey wrote:
Mon May 08, 2017 9:45:36 pm
Why would we tell you who we're voting for when we think they have the idol, and you're aligned with them? You could tell them as a heads up?
I didn't need to know the vote, but I would've liked to know you thought he had an idol. Like, valuable information.
User avatar
 

Nick

  • Juror
  • Posts: 1337
By Trish
#3154 it might also be worth noting that this confessional was literally the most positive confessional i've ever seen lol. the kind of positivity u would never expect in one lol
User avatar
 

Trish

  • Juror
  • Posts: 252
By Lindsey
#3155
Andrea wrote:
Mon May 08, 2017 9:47:04 pm
Lindsey wrote:
Mon May 08, 2017 9:45:36 pm
Why would we tell you who we're voting for when we think they have the idol, and you're aligned with them? You could tell them as a heads up?
i mean why wouldn't you make sure you had all 6 voting with you. there's a lot about last vote i don't understand, lol.
Yeah, there's a lot about last vote I don't understand either, but it wouldn't have made the difference.
User avatar
 

Lindsey

  • Juror
  • Posts: 675
By Nick
#3156
Tai wrote:
Mon May 08, 2017 9:47:33 pm
Garrett for #GameChangers

because this boy is still relevant. LOL
Garrett should be on Stranded with Game Changers for sure.
User avatar
 

Nick

  • Juror
  • Posts: 1337
By Spencer
#3157
Andrea wrote:
Mon May 08, 2017 9:46:08 pm
Spencer wrote:
Mon May 08, 2017 9:45:22 pm
Lindsey wrote:
Mon May 08, 2017 9:39:28 pm


you didn't see the "accidental" confessional he posted to the tribe page about lying to Garrett about having the idol. Seemed too coincidental.
I told Garrett about having an idol the night Woo was voted off, I accidentally posted a confessional in the tribe forum admitting I'd lied about it like a day or two later, and I guess Garrett told them I had an idol like an hour before I posted it, so that looked suspicious. I didn't know he told them until yesterday so it's literally just a coincidence.
why did you tell garrett you had an idol, though? and why would he believe it, where would you have gotten it??
I told him I found the HII for our tribe bc he was freaking out about his brother being voted out; this was during the hour where I was trying to console him and he was telling me he was crying and that he would commit septku for me in game, so I was kinda freaked out and I just wanted him to calm down.
User avatar
 

Spencer

  • Juror
  • Posts: 564
By Andrea
#3158
Lindsey wrote:
Mon May 08, 2017 9:48:10 pm
Andrea wrote:
Mon May 08, 2017 9:47:04 pm
Lindsey wrote:
Mon May 08, 2017 9:45:36 pm
Why would we tell you who we're voting for when we think they have the idol, and you're aligned with them? You could tell them as a heads up?
i mean why wouldn't you make sure you had all 6 voting with you. there's a lot about last vote i don't understand, lol.
Yeah, there's a lot about last vote I don't understand either, but it wouldn't have made the difference.
fair enough!
User avatar
 

Andrea

  • Juror
  • Posts: 1315
By Lindsey
#3159
Nick wrote:
Mon May 08, 2017 9:47:36 pm
Lindsey wrote:
Mon May 08, 2017 9:45:36 pm
Why would we tell you who we're voting for when we think they have the idol, and you're aligned with them? You could tell them as a heads up?
I didn't need to know the vote, but I would've liked to know you thought he had an idol. Like, valuable information.
It's not like you're asking me "Hey Lindsey, who are you thinking has the idols?" If you did, I'd be straight up. Ask, and you shall learn.
User avatar
 

Lindsey

  • Juror
  • Posts: 675
By Andrea
#3160
Spencer wrote:
Mon May 08, 2017 9:48:32 pm
Andrea wrote:
Mon May 08, 2017 9:46:08 pm
Spencer wrote:
Mon May 08, 2017 9:45:22 pm


I told Garrett about having an idol the night Woo was voted off, I accidentally posted a confessional in the tribe forum admitting I'd lied about it like a day or two later, and I guess Garrett told them I had an idol like an hour before I posted it, so that looked suspicious. I didn't know he told them until yesterday so it's literally just a coincidence.
why did you tell garrett you had an idol, though? and why would he believe it, where would you have gotten it??
I told him I found the HII for our tribe bc he was freaking out about his brother being voted out; this was during the hour where I was trying to console him and he was telling me he was crying and that he would commit septku for me in game, so I was kinda freaked out and I just wanted him to calm down.
oh god, the septku.

so you were like, i have the idol, we can use it together, you'll be fine?
User avatar
 

Andrea

  • Juror
  • Posts: 1315

Treemail